Gurney's Montauk Resort & Seawater Spa

Very unprofessional staff at the lobby . They never returned any of my calls and they didn't take care of any of the requests. Disappointing for the price we paid for the night.

Resort was clean and all staff work masks and socially distanced. Lots of hand sanitizer stations throughout the property. Our room was very quiet, couldn't hear anyone else. Only downside was the construction on Friday, but it didn't start too early or go through the weekend which was good. Beach chairs were all spaced far apart, most guests respected others space and wore masks indoors.

When we booked, I'm not sure we had the option to choose whether we had an oceanfront room, so when we arrived to find our room looked out onto a parking lot, we were disappointed. If it had been made clear that we wouldn't have the opportunity to have a beachfront room due to a discounted price I wouldn't have felt as ripped off, but it did impact the overall experience. Otherwise, the hotel service was fabulous and most of the staff were exception and very kind.

Great location. The lunch/brunch service was a bit slow, but quality of food was very good. The pool area was a bit run down, and drafty. The men’s hot tub was closed and I was told by someone else it was same story last winter! I feel for the money they charge, they should keep up on things a bit more.

We went off season, what a relaxing experience. I got exactly what I wanted!! Got a weekend of pampering, which included a massage and facial. Swimming in the pool. All of the staff was extremely nice and accommodating, especially Nick. The food was good, however, all portions were very small. Even reserved an igloo.

Everything was wonderful ,all the staff there super great, had the best vacation ever👍

Gurney's is amazing! The service was top notch. We were originally put in a room overlooking the parking lot, and we're moved to a higher rate room with expansive ocean views for no additional charge. The room itself was not renovated, but the view more than made up for some wear and tear on the carpet. The hotel itself is situated in such a beautiful spot, can't ask for a more picture perfect view in all of Montauk!

We went to Gurneys quite a bit 10+ years ago but avoided it when it became more of a club scene. We decided to give it a try with our 11 and 9 yr old. Unfortunately, it seems like they really haven't figured out who they are looking to attract. It was a mix of NYC and Westchester families and 20 something Jersey shore partiers debating whether to party at Gurneys or Surf Lodge. They sold beach access to all buyers including $2,500 Cabanas. Some guests were drunk or on drugs passed out in hammocks next to blaring speakers. Not the environment we were hoping for with the kids. Some staff were lovely while others were arrogant. The valet damaged our vehicle and took no responsibility. The restaurant hostess was not polite about reservations and there were plenty of available tables. Everything was ridiculously priced. My kids were up till 2:30am with the house music partying going on. Location is great and there isn't much quality inventory in Montauk. Pretty disappointed overall that Gurneys has lost the Montauk charm we remember.

Fabulous location at Montauk Beach LI, a great stress free fun in the sun experience

It was first family trip with my 8 month old baby, staying in Gurney's was such a gift for my family. The resort offers convenient valet parking and fabulous in-hotel restaurants. people there were all very friendly and very helpful, wish we would go back there soon!