Beachcomber at Montauk

Pros: the room was spacious and well-appointed, with an ocean view. Cons: the ceiling could have used more soundproofing (audible footsteps at all hours), and the floor was sandy (but we were at the beach.) We plan to return to this hotel.

Amazing! The room was beautiful staff was very kind. Highly recommend. Will be coming back!

Right by beach quiet

Loved the Beachcomber, great location, close to town and right across the street from the beach. View from room was amazing. Will definitely stay here again.

We had a great stay. There were a lot of amenities and it was in a great location. The only thing I would complain about was the bed, the mattress was very uncomfortable. Other than that, the room was great.

Nice large room with great ocean view in a nice complex with a great pool. Considering the price, the room needs better lighting ( it is very dark) and more outlets to charge electronics. The closet door was also off the track, but other than those minor issues, a very nice place to stay.

Great location and amenities. Spacious room- could be updated.

Like most of Montauk, this hotel is over-priced, but has a better location and a pool than others, so if you are going to Montauk (especially if you have children with you), this is the place to stay.

The Beachcomber is a comfortable condo across street from beach. Rooms seem to be owned by an independent owner so what you get in your room may vary. Room 231 is very well maintained, cute beach decorations and comfortable bed. Pool and bath towels are included (cannot take to beach). The room also had small toiletries (like you would see in a hotel). There was also dish soap, a sponge, paper towels, and dishwashing pods. If you need anything else (including coffee filters for the coffee pot), bring them with you. The pool is open until 7P only which is a little odd b/c it doesn't seem to have a 'real' lifeguard there, would be great if open later at a swim at your own risk type of situation. The beach is across the street - you do have to cross a busy street but the beach was very private and even going during the 'high' season it almost seemed that we had the whole beach to ourselves. The place itself is a bit 'outside' of the main town which is really nice if you are looking for a bit more relaxed vibe. It is walking distance to town/restaurants. We chose to drive into town and had no problem finding parking on the street (again in the 'busy' season). My complaints were minimal - resort fee is quite high (not really sure what it was for). Also, we asked for a late checkout and we had to call multiple times only to be told finally call 'day of' and then were still told it wasn't possible. Otherwise, really nice place, close to town and all attractions while still relaxing

Overall we had a good stay. GREAT location, and nice grounds. Beach right across the street although heads up that it is not the beach with the lifeguard. And bring beach towels, they only provide pool towels.The rules at the pool were overly strict. They were not allowing kids to jump in the pool. I understand diving but no jumping seemed odd to me for a family place.